3 Questions: St. Louis Cardinals | Disciples of Uecker

Disciples of Uecker

We'd like to go to the Playoffs, that would be cool.

This is the 5th in an ongoing series previewing the 6 teams in the National League Central.

You can read the previous pieces on the Astros [here],  on the Cubs [here],  on the Pirates [here], and on the Reds [here].

1) How much will age impact the team?

It’s no secret that the core of the St. Louis roster has gotten a little long in the tooth. Many of their best players, including Chris Carpenter (37), Lance Berkman (36), Carlos Beltran (35), Rafael Furcal (34), and Matt Holliday (32) are well past their age-30 seasons and either in career decline or quickly approaching it. That’s not to say they aren’t talented or capable of producing at high levels, because they are and most have recent histories of still good production. It’s just that when any player ages, it brings along added risk of injury and general decline. Carpenter is already on the disabled list to start the season, and it’s hard to imagine a scenario where he’s the only key veteran on the roster to miss some time. Even if collectively they are able to maintain a reasonable level of health, it’s quite possible that their combined performance won’t live up to expectations simply due to aging. In the end, if they all perform reasonably well, there is no reason they can’t make up for the departure of Albert Pujols and maybe then some, but they still have to get on the field and do it and they’re not off to a great start in that department.

2) Will Adam Wainwright return to his previous ace level performance? 

It’s easy for fans to take for granted that players will perform up to their previous levels after having elbow ligament replacement (or Tommy John) surgery these days because of the impressive record of success of the procedure, but it’s not nearly that simple in reality. First off, while the success rate is high, it’s not perfect. There are also players that end up having to undergo the procedure again because they never fixed the mechanical issue that caused the problem in the first place. Finally, even though the recovery time is now down to 9-12 months, it still often takes pitchers longer to regain their velocity and command. With Carpenter already on the disabled list, it’s that much more important for the Cardinals that Wainwright performs at a high level. If he’s unable to do so or suffers a setback in health, the Cards rotation could have trouble keeping the team in games. Until we see him a few times in real game action, it’s hard to say one way or another just what the team might get out of him.

3) How will the team respond to the changes in the clubhouse hierarchy?

Understanding and managing the dynamics of a major league clubhouse is a tricky thing even for people who spend every day living it. It’s part of why not every tactically qualified managerial candidate proves successful. Therefore, it’s hard to say just how important former manager Tony LaRussa and star Albert Pujols were in maintaining the atmosphere that kept the club competitive over most of the last decade. Just because we can’t measure it, doesn’t mean it’s not a potential problem, though. The Cards have entrusted the highly regarded Mike Matheny with keeping the train on the tracks, but he has zero managerial experience at any level. Beyond him, how will the rest of the team respond in Pujols’ absence? He was such a presence both in the lineup and as a personality, it will be interesting to see what happens now that he’s not there. The old power structure generally maintained an “us against the world” mentality that kept the team pulling in at least mostly in the same direction, young center fielders aside. Will the new regime be able to do that, or at least find something else that can work? If they can’t, it could keep the talent from shining through and push the team down in the standings.

Share Our Posts

Share this post through social bookmarks.

  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • Newsvine
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati


Tell us what do you think.

  1. Andrew says: April 3, 2012

    How exactly was Pujols personality a cornerstone? If you’ve paid attention, he’s never been the leader of the Cards for the past 11 years. At least not as a clubhouse personality.

    • Ryan Topp says: April 3, 2012

      Yeah, the third one was something of a stretch from the get go, certainly harder to quantify or nail down than the other two more directly performance related questions. I’ve now written 5 of these things, and I’m trying to keep them as fresh as possible as I go without too much repeating, though that’s been tough at times. Still, I think there is a question of leadership there that could potentially impact things. Brewer fans saw how having someone that many players simply hated hurt the team over the two Macha years. It does matter, and I do think it’s a valid question to ask.

      On the Pujols thing specifically, I’m simply going by what I’ve read and what I’ve seen myself about him. I know he wasn’t a “rah rah” sort of a guy in the clubhouse, but I do think his presence mattered. How he went about doing things mattered. If nothing else, people took some cues from him about what was expected from players on the Cardinals. I really didn’t mean anything more than that he was a pacesetter on that team, and that his loss isn’t just about production but also presence. Hopefully that clears things up.

  2. Nicholas Zettel says: April 3, 2012

    Carlos Beltran is 35!?

    Did you happen to see the MLB.com fluff piece on Matheny, by any chance? There’s this great sequence that discusses his ability to speak with players in Spanish. Therefore, World Series.

    • Ryan Topp says: April 3, 2012

      Yeah, he’s 35. I think he’s trying to pick up a ring at the end here to help bolster his HOF case. He really should be one, but I suspect that his time with the NYM and their perpetual disappointment thing is going to hurt him with the less progressive voters.

      Anyway, no I didn’t see that thing about Matheny, but it sounds par for the course this time of year. I’m really interested to see how Matheny handles the job, if he tries to mimic someone’s style or if he’s really got ideas of his own he wants to try and put into practice. I have a hard time believing the team will play with the chip they’ve had on their shoulder for as long as I can remember now.


Websites mentioned my entry.

There are no trackbacks on this entry

Add a Comment

Fill in the form and submit.