Ryan Braun, Starlin Castro, and Moral Outrage | Disciples of Uecker

Disciples of Uecker

We'd like to go to the Playoffs, that would be cool.

This year, my roommates really don’t care that much about sports. As far as I can tell, the only reason they watched Game Five of the National League Division Series with me was to watch my incredibly over-the-top reactions and yelling at every single pitch. But lo and behold, there they were, roughly one hour after reports of Ryan Braun’s positive drug test popped up on ESPN, asking me if I had heard about it, what I thought, if I could still be a Ryan Braun fan, etc.

Today, reports has surfaced that Starlin Castro may have sexually assaulted a woman at his apartment in Chicago during the fall. I will not hear about it from my roommates. SportsCenter is talking about the new head football coach at Penn State, and the “What’s Next” box shows nothing about Starlin Castro upcoming for discussion.

Where is the widespread moral outrage against the Cubs’ star? Sexual assault is one of the worst crimes a human being can commit, and yet the sports world seems perfectly content to move on as if nothing has happened.

True, Castro is innocent until proven guilty. True, there are times when we see these things blow over as the alleged victim recants the story. But from either a rash of ignorance — for some reason, this story really isn’t getting out there among the big baseball reporters (Jon Heyman is tweeting about Brandon Webb, whose major league career is probably over) — or a rash of apathy, this story just seems like any other headline for another day on the cold stove.

Obviously this was not the case with Ryan Braun. Nearly every national writer offered some opinion on the case within a few days, many of them harshly judging him for his actions. Comments sections for articles involving him are typically met with comments of “CHEATER!” early and often. Many around baseball have already renounced him; in their eyes, his career will always be tainted by PEDs. And while it’s true that he did test positive, we still don’t know what the cause of the positive test is. The most recent report said that the test was for a personal medication, something that would still draw a 50-game suspension but seems hardly worthy of our moral outrage.

The mental and emotional impacts of sexual assault — rape — can be and often are lifelong for the victim. An actual person greatly impacted by the behavior of the player, not some abstract cause like “sanctity of the game” or other such platitudes. It is a crime on a magnitude so much greater than cheating at baseball — a game, something we watch as a distraction, an escape, pure entertainment. Our moral axis when it comes to sports has been shifted and scrambled to a point where we only care about things that impact the play on the field, so shifted that we can lose sight of things that actually matter. Like other real, living and breathing human beings.

Share Our Posts

Share this post through social bookmarks.

  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • Newsvine
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati


Tell us what do you think.

  1. cravizzle says: January 6, 2012

    Its on ESPN’s website now http://espn.go.com/chicago/mlb/story/_/id/7431695/chicago-cubs-starlin-castro-part-sexual-assault-investigation

    Still haven’t seen on TV though.

    That being said Castro is not the reigning NL MVP, or the face of his franchise, or one of the rising stars of the league. Not trying to diminish what Sterlin is being accused of, but when a star is accused of using a substance to do better, something that the MLB has had major problems with, its going to be a MAJOR story and get a lot of coverage.

    Like it or not like it that is just the fact of major media.

  2. bbbobbb says: January 6, 2012

    True, Castro is not the reigning NL MVP. I’d argue that he is, however, “the face of his franchise.” I know enough Cubs fans, and he’s the guy they count on for the future. He is also undoubtedly “one of the rising stars of the league.” The guy has hit .300 in both of his MLB seasons and made an All Star team at age 21. If that’s not the resume of a “rising star”, I’m not sure what is. You can argue that the Castro situation shouldn’t be reported as the Braun situation was, but not for the reason that Castro isn’t enough of a player to merit the attention. He is.

  3. Poppy says: January 6, 2012

    Not defending Castro one bit, but it’s pretty simple. People care about the game: what Castro allegedly did doesn’t affect the game. What Braun allegedly did certainly affects the integrity of the game.

  4. Cale says: January 10, 2012

    You guys are missing the exact point of this well written article. Since when does the “integrity of the game” matter more than a woman’s rights? What if that woman was your wife/sister/mother? I’m sure you’d think differently then.

  5. Pete says: January 12, 2012

    This story, and the point you bring up, to me, parallels every sports writer/personality lining up to drool over Ray Lewis as the greatest LB of all time and a great mentor to the younger players on the Ravens. The fact remains that he once murdered a man with a knife. But all is forgotten because he is such a dynamic player. Now Ndamakung Suh and James Harrison are villified on a much greater scale than he is because the unfortunate things they have done relate to the game and get brought up constantly on the 24/7 news cycle.


Websites mentioned my entry.

There are no trackbacks on this entry

Add a Comment

Fill in the form and submit.