“In your opinion, what is our starting rotation 1-5 going to look like next year?” — @tdepp34
Too many moving parts exist at this point to make any definitive predictions. Prior to the 2011, Brewers fans witnessed that when Doug Melvin pulled off back-to-back blockbuster trades that sent Shaun Marcum and Zack Greinke to Milwaukee — which dramatically overhauled the starting rotation in a way that even the most optimistic fan could have foreseen.
With that said, the starting rotation picture is slowly becoming more clear. Here’s my far-too-early prediction for next year’s rotation:
1) Yovani Gallardo
2) Free Agent SP
3) Mike Fiers
4) Mark Rogers
5) Marco Estrada
This would leave top prospect Wily Peralta in Nashville to sort out his severe command issues that have resurfaced this year, and right-hander Tyler Thornburg would likely begin the season in the big league bullpen. Chris Narveson will certainly remain in the picture, but far too many question marks surround a guy coming off season-ending shoulder surgery to project him in the starting rotation. Perhaps Narveson is better off as a situational lefty out of the bullpen.
“Updates on Coulter and Jungman, if you got info.” — @TStads20
Milwaukee drafted Clint Coulter with their first pick of the 2012 Draft for his bat, not his defensive chops behind the plate, and that has played out in his professional debut in the Arizona League. Scouts like his bat. It also seems to be a consensus amongst scouts that Coulter has almost no chance to remain behind the plate — which is evidenced by his 22 passed balls in 25 games and a paltry 16% caught stealing percentage. Whether he ends up at third base or a corner outfield position, however, remains to be seen.
Taylor Jungmann hasn’t wowed anyone with a 3.65 ERA and 5.66 K/9 strikeout rate in the pitcher-friendly Florida State League. His pedestrian numbers can partially be ascribed to a new curveball grip he has switched to midseason, which naturally takes some time to develop comfort. His changeup has also progressed more slowly than most scouts thought when Milwaukee drafted him out of the University of Texas. Few doubt he will be a starting pitcher in the big leagues in some capacity. It simply seems it may only be as a #3 or #4 starter.
“If Marcum could be had for a year with an option, how much would you pay?” — @bachlaw
On a one-year deal, I wouldn’t be afraid to offer $8-10M with a club option for 2014. The health concerns stop the offer from being anything more, which is also to say that I would not feel comfortable giving Marcum a qualifying offer this winter. Even if that sacrifices the potential for compensation picks in the 2013 Draft.
Shaun Marcum provides significant value when healthy, but he has thrown more than 200 innings just once in his career. Offering north of $10M — even on a one year deal — on a pitcher with such significant red flags would not be a prudent move for the organization, in my eyes.
“Is there any thought o having Lucroy learn a new position? Maldonado should be the starting catcher.” — @biasauth
In my mind, that’s not even an option. Jonathan Lucroy provides significant value to the Brewers at the catcher position, and he doesn’t have a natural home elsewhere. Some talk has floated around the Brewers’ blogosphere that he could learn second or third base — though I haven’t witnessed anything that would suggest (A) that he could even be average defensively at either position, or (B) that the organization has even considered anything remotely close to that. Not to mention Aramis Ramirez and Rickie Weeks are firmly entrenched in their respective positions.
The main issue, however, is that Martin Maldonado doesn’t profile well as an everyday catcher. He has been a pleasant surprise, no doubt, but his lofty .336 wOBA has been bolstered by a .341 BABIP. Maldonado is exactly what a team wants in a backup catcher. He possesses a very strong arm, above-average receiving skills, and some pop in his bat. His approach at the plate would likely prevent him from sustaining success over 400 or 500 plate appearances over the course of an entire season, though.
I’m also expecting a decline at the plate for Maldonado next season. Baseball is a game of adjustments. Opposing pitchers will undoubtedly adjust to his overly-aggressive approach. It will be interesting to see if he can adjust as well.
“How come bases per plate appearance isn’t a stat that’s ever used? It’s easy to figure and seems somewhat relevant.” — @DarthZilcho
The main problem, in my mind, stems from the fact that bases per plate appearance would attempt to be an encompassing offensive statistic, and much better ones (wOBA, wRC+, etc.) exist and tell us significantly more about a player and his production.
“Who would be the first Brewers position player to pitch an inning if absolutely necessary?” — @NearfallKing
This is a great question.
In terms of pure arm strength, one would like to see Carlos Gomez or Martin Maldonado step on the mound and let it loose. That’s obviously unlikely, though. Teams need to protect their assets, which is why the position player most likely to see the mound is generally a fungible bench player (i.e. Joe Inglett or Trent Durrington).
If I had to guess, the first Brewers position player to see the mound would be Cody Ransom — though the idea of Travis Ishikawa on the mound is rather entertaining.
“Which pitching prospects should Brewers fans expect to see on the major league roster in September or next season?” — @mmm9731
Expect to see Mike Fiers and Mark Rogers (if healthy) on the Brewers’ roster through Opening Day next season. It becomes rather difficult to project the remainder of the pitching staff, however, as the Brewers have a plethora of arms in their upper levels of the minors who could potentially see some time at the big league level.
Here is a brief rundown of some arms who could threaten to break into the big leagues in some capacity over the next year:
Fautino De Los Santos
And those are just some of the names. Obviously, pitchers such as Nelson and Pena would have to put together hot starts to the 2013 season to have a chance to reaching the big leagues, but all of those arms have some shot to pitch in Milwaukee over the next year.